Why I’m Not Hugely Keen on Google+. Yet.
Google+; it’s the exciting and hot new social network on the web. Everybody’s clamouring for invites, because the beta is taking the concept of social network in a brave new direction by making it difficult to get on. Who cares if you can’t communicate with everyone you want to? Exclusivity – That’s what it’s about these days.
Anyway, the stupid invite limiting isn’t what puts me off. My real problem with it is the interface.
Pictures speak louder than words, so I’ll just start off by putting these three screengrabs of comments I have made on Facebook, Twitter, and Google+. These are all screengrabbed off my computer, running Chrome with default font size etc. They’re all cropped to the top and bottom of the post horizontal rule. Each of my posts has a couple of follow up comments by other users, the Facebook and G+ ones both have a “like” / “+1″.
(Sorry about all the blacking out, but I don’t feel it’s really my place to publish other people’s comments, even if they are just on the banality of my own eating.)
The Twitter grab spells out my problem explicitly. My desktop is 900 pixels high. When I load G+ I can see fewer posts than on either of the other two social sites. This seems very bad to me, I like to be able to quickly browse the goings on in my networks, and then interact with those that interest me. G+ makes browsing much more time consuming.
It’s a problem made worse by the inlining of images and video at their native resolutions. At least Facebook has learnt to crop and scale to keep things from taking up too much room.
If one user has posted three updates in a row, they have taken over my entire G+ screen. It feels like they are spamming me. The same three posts take up just a quarter of my Twitter feed view, so it doesn’t feel like they’re taking over.
Circles (as nice an idea as they are, and they’re certainly the main thing I hear people talking positively about) don’t help in this situation. A noisy user is a noisy user. The only thing I could do is put them in a circle by themselves, or a “7th Circle of Spam”, or something. This might be exacerbated by people not yet having worked out where G+ “fits” into their social life. Is it designed for high volume posting like Twitter, or is fewer richer posts, like Facebook?
Still, it is a worry for me that with the dozen or so people I currently have on the network, my feed is already feeling overloaded.
(And yes, I know I could send them feedback, but I’m not sure it should really be up to me to help companies make their products be something I want to use. I already have two networks that serve my needs pretty well. I can’t believe that everybody in a position to influence this at Google thought that a huge font and no theme support was the right way to go.)
- 3 Comments »
-
Posted by FreakyZoid on Sunday, July 3, 2011 at 3:12 pm
Tags: Stuff





